Back to blog
bkd.ai blog

How long should a rep keep a returning lead before it's reassigned?

Long enough to show they are still working it. A good rule is that a returning lead stays with its rep if the rep touched it recently, and goes back into the rotation once it has been quiet for a set number of days. bkd.ai lets the dealership pick that number.

Jason MayhewNovember 16, 20263 min read

Why is reassigning a returning lead a hard call?

Because both answers are sometimes right. A customer who comes back while their rep is mid-conversation should stay with that rep. A customer who comes back after their rep stopped calling months ago deserves a fresh set of eyes. A single on or off switch treats both customers the same way.

Always keep them with the original rep and you reward the rep who stopped following up. Always reassign and you take a live deal away from the rep who was about to close it, and the customer gets a stranger mid-conversation.

What you actually want to know is whether anyone is working this customer right now. That is a question about recent activity, not about who owned them first. What the owning rep should do the moment a lead returns is its own question, which we covered in what should happen when an old lead comes back.

What counts as working a lead?

Working a lead means real contact or real effort in the last few days: the rep was assigned it, or texted, called, emailed or wrote a note on it. Any of those inside the window means someone is on it. None of them means the customer has been sitting, and a fresh rep is fair.

Notes count on purpose. A rep who talked to the customer on the lot and wrote it down did the work, even if no text or call went through the system.

Being assigned the lead counts too. A rep who got the customer two days ago hasn't had a fair chance yet, whatever the activity log says.

How many quiet days should a dealership wait?

There is no single right number, and it depends on how fast your store's deals move. A store that sells mostly off the lot in a week can use a short window. A finance-heavy store where deals take weeks to come together needs a longer one, or it will pull customers from reps mid-approval.

Start with the gap your managers already use when they ask a rep "are you still working this one?" If the answer is usually yes inside a week, a week is your number.

Then watch where returning leads land for a month and adjust. If reps keep asking for customers back, the window is too short. If returning customers sit untouched, it is too long.

How does bkd.ai decide who gets a returning lead?

In bkd.ai, an admin turns on Re-distribute returning leads and picks When: right away, or after a set number of quiet days. A returning lead stays with its rep if they got it, texted, called, emailed or noted it inside that window. Otherwise it goes to the next rep in the rotation.

The card shows a Live line that says what will happen in plain words, so nobody has to guess what the setting does. Nothing changes for a store until an admin picks a number. Right away stays the default.

Campaigns that need their own rule can keep it. A campaign's Reassign returning customers rule uses the same quiet-days check, and the card shows how many campaigns use their own rule.

Frequently asked questions

Does a returning lead get reassigned automatically in bkd.ai?

It depends on the Re-distribute returning leads setting. With it off, a returning lead stays with its original rep. With it on, the admin chooses whether the lead moves right away or only after it has been quiet for a set number of days.

What counts as quiet for a returning lead?

A lead is quiet when, inside the window the dealership picked, its rep was not assigned it and did not text, call, email or write a note on it. If any of those happened inside the window, the lead stays with that rep when the customer comes back.

Can a campaign use a different rule for returning leads?

Yes. A campaign can carry its own Reassign returning customers rule, and that rule wins over the dealership setting for leads from that campaign. It uses the same quiet-days check. The Returning Leads card shows how many campaigns use their own rule, so nothing is hidden.

Get the BKD Newsletter in your inbox

Dealership growth tactics and product updates. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Let's build this together.

We're not selling software. We're inviting 30 dealer owners to help us build the CRM you've always wanted—one your team will actually use.

30 spots • Dedicated support • Founding pricing locked forever